Call

Text

Free Roof Inspections and Estimates

Call 970-395-0406

Text us

Free Roof Inspections and Estimates

Are Steel Shingles Worth It

April 22, 2025

sample of a steel shake roof

More Coloradans are searching for an asphalt shingle or wood shake roof alternative – one that’s more durable and lasts longer. After all, traditional asphalt shingles only last 15-25 years, even less if you live in a part of the state that gets large hailstones. For many folks, an alternative to asphalt shingles is steel shingles or shake. But are steel shingles or shakes worth it?

Quick Answer: Yes! Stone-coated steel shingles or shakes are definitely worth the extra cost because they last 3x longer than traditional asphalt shingles or real wood shakes, which means you’ll spend less in the long run. Think you can’t afford it? We offer roof financing.

What Are Steel Shingles

view of the underside of a steel roofing shake

Steel shingles, as well as steel shake and steel tiles, is a relatively new type of metal roof covering. They consist of a base layer of tin, followed by a layer of asphalt, which acts as the adhesive which holds the top layer of granules. Traditional asphalt shingles have a fiberglass base layer. Steel shingles resemble traditional asphalt shingles, while steel shake resembles wood shake and steel tiles resemble Spanish barrel tiles or Pacific tiles.

Stone-Coated Steel Roof Options

There are many stone-coated steel roof options available, today. We offer stone-coated metal roofing products from Decra and Westlake Royal Roofing.

sample of stone-coated steel shingle roof

Steel Shingles

Prefer the look of traditional asphalt shingle but want your roof to last longer? Consider stone-coated steel shingles. Unlike traditional asphalt shingles, steel shingles are recyclable.

sample of stone-coated steel shake roof

Steel Shake

If you’re looking for an alternative to a wood shake roof, consider stone-coated steel shake. It’s much more durable and longer-lasting than wood, and costs less in the long run.

samples of stone-coated Spanish barrel roofing tiles

Steel Barrel Tiles

Consider these Spanish barrel stone-coated steel roofing tiles if you prefer the authentic look of Spanish clay tiles, but want your roof to last longer.

Pacific stone-coated steel roofing tile sample

Pacific Steel Tiles

For those looking for a unique roof, consider Pacific stone-coated steel roofing tiles. These tiles offer a Mediterranean style that provides both high wind and hail impact resistance.

Benefits of Steel Shingles, Shake, and Tile

Cost

For many, it comes down to cost. Many find stone-coated steel shingles worth the extra initial cost and a good alternative to asphalt shingles. Steel shingles and shakes cost less in the long run because they last so much longer than traditional asphalt shingles.

Durability

Steel is much more durable than fiberglass, which is the base material traditional asphalt shingles are made of. Steel shingles are installed with screws, which offer much better holding power than nails, which are used to secure traditional asphalt shingles.

Longevity

Traditional asphalt shingles last 15-30 years if undamaged by hail and regularly maintained. A new stone-coated steel shingle or shake roof, however, should last 70 years or more, even if it’s damaged by hail. That’s because steel is much more durable than fiberglass, which is the base layer of traditional asphalt shingles.

Fewer Reroofs

A long-lasting roof means fewer reroofs. During the lifespan of one steel shingle or shake roof, a traditional asphalt shingle roof will have been replaced 2 or 3 times.

Curb Appeal

Stone-coated steel shakes more closely resemble real wood shakes. Therefore, they look more realistic. Steel shingles, shakes, and tiles also maintain their visual appearance longer than traditional asphalt shingles and wood shakes.

Increased Home Value

Studies show that a new metal roof indicates the home has been well maintained and cared for. It also increases the home’s resale value. When potential buyers learn a home has a metal roof, they know that’s one less thing they have to worry about. The home is that much closer to move-in ready.

Recyclability

Traditional asphalt shingles aren’t recyclable in our area. Therefore, when we remove a worn-out asphalt shingle roof, we deliver it to the nearest landfill. Stone-coated steel shingles, on the other hand, are recyclable in our area.

aerial view of new stone-coated metal roofing shingles on a home
A new steel shake roof we installed in Greeley, Colorado

Are You Ready for a Longer-Lasting Roof (and to save money)?

Contact us for a free estimate on a new stone-coated steel shingle or shake roof today!
Financing available.

5-year workmanship guarantee seal

Are Steel Shingles Worth It To You

Given the low long-term cost and long lifespan, are steel shingles worth it to you? More Coloradans are saying yes. This Greeley homeowner was tired of having his traditional asphalt shingle roof replaced after hail damage, so he asked us to install a new steel shake roof. He felt steel shake was a better alternative to asphalt shingles. If you’d like to discuss whether stone-coated steel shingles are worth it, and whether they’re worth the extra money, contact us for a free, no-obligation chat. We’re happy to answer any and all questions you might have about steel shingles.

Steel Shingle Roof Installation

Are you looking for a roofing company in Northern Colorado to install your new steel shingle or shake roof? You’ve come to the right place. We love metal roofing, primarily because it lasts so long. Metal is simply a superior roof covering. What’s more, it makes us feel better to recycle an old metal roof rather than bury asphalt shingles in our backyard. We offer quality steel roofing products from Westlake Royal Roofing and Decra.

5-year workmanship guarantee seal

Guaranteed – We offer a 5-year workmanship guarantee on all new steel shingle and shake roofs we install.

Experience – We have over 40 years roofing experience in Colorado.

Covered – We’re fully licensed and insured. This protects your property and our employees.